Prior user rights | Intellepedia

Prior user rights prevail over subsequent registration, reiterates court

Cartoon-style image inspired by the Bollywood song "Saree Ke Fall Sa," featuring a woman (Sonakshi Sinha) in a neon green and pink saree and a man (Shahid Kapoor) in a grey outfit dancing against a blue background. Both are mid-step, with expressive hand gestures. Musical notes on the left include the text “Saree ke Fall ka match kiya re...”

Delhi HC cancels ‘Ragini’ label for deceptive similarity and copied trade dress, upholding prior user rights of ‘Rani’/‘Rachna’ and ordering Section 57 rectification of the register.

Newer ‘Blue-Jay’ Mark knocked off the League

The Delhi High Court has struck down the ‘BLUE-JAY’ trademark, siding with Major League Baseball against PMS Creations. The Court held that MLB’s prior use and transborder reputation trumped the respondents’ registration, which was tainted by dishonesty and bad faith.

Subsequent User’s ‘Suguna’ Trademark for Grinders Rectified Despite Proof of Use from 2001

The Madras High Court cancelled the SUGUNA trademark registration for grinders, favouring prior user rights of the petitioners with established goodwill since 1959. The respondent’s claims of honest concurrent use were rejected due to insufficient evidence.

Court holds that FIELDMARSHAL Trademark belongs to PM Diesel, the Prior, Continuous and Legitimate User

The Delhi High Court has ruled that the FIELDMARSHAL trademark belongs to PM Diesel, recognising its prior, continuous, and legitimate use. Thukral’s claims were dismissed, and reliefs including actual litigation costs and registration of pending applications were granted to PM Diesel.