Summary
NRB Bearings Limited and NRB Industrial Bearings Limited split in 2012 under a court-approved demerger, and the second company received the NRB Industrial trademark only for industrial bearings. When it launched automotive bearings under that mark in July 2026, NRB sought interim relief pending arbitration. The Bombay High Court held that the right to run a business is distinct from the right to use a trademark in it, and that a Class 12 registration does not defeat a passing off claim. It restrained use of the mark on mobile vehicle bearings but refused a receiver and cancellation. The ruling matters for every demerger, family settlement and brand-split agreement.
Background
Sixty-one years of goodwill in three letters, a Rs. 55.12 crore settlement and a demerger order from 2012 collided before the Bombay High Court, which had to decide whether the NRB Industrial trademark, licensed for industrial bearings, can travel into automotive bearings.
NRB Bearings Limited (“NRB”) was incorporated in 1965 and holds about 36 registrations for NRB. A Scheme of Arrangement approved by the court on 24 August 2012 (“Scheme”) transferred its Industrial Bearings Undertaking to NRB Industrial Bearings Limited (“NIBL”). Clause 1.5.5(c) of the Scheme passed the mark “NRB Industrial” for bearings for industrial application to NIBL, but declared that “NRB” and its associated description, design, colour and logo stayed NRB’s exclusive property. A 2012 agreement then barred each company from the other’s business for six years, until 30 September 2018, and said nothing about trade marks.
On 29 April 2016, NIBL applied under the Trade Marks Act, 1999 (“Trade Marks Act”) for NRB INDUSTRIAL (label) in Class 12, covering motor vehicle bearings, and obtained registration on 21 February 2018 with effect from the filing date. On 20 January 2025, the parties signed an Inter-Company Agreement (“ICA 2025”) as part of a family settlement, and NRB paid NIBL Rs. 55.12 crore. NRB had proposed during negotiations that NIBL cancel the Class 12 registration, but that clause was deleted from the final text. On 17 July 2026, NIBL launched automotive bearings, and its closing slide read “NRB INDUSTRIAL BEARINGS LIMITED | NRB GROUP” on a blue background. After a cease and desist notice dated 18 July 2026, NRB sought interim relief under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 pending arbitration. The court reserved judgment on 30 October 2026 and pronounced it on 4 November 2026.
Issues
-
- Whether Clause 1.5.5(c) of the Scheme and Clauses 4.1 and 4.2 of ICA 2025 confine NIBL’s use of “NRB Industrial”, “NRB Industrial Bearings” and “NRB INDL” to industrial bearings.
- Whether the expiry of the six-year non-compete on 30 September 2018, or the deletion of the proposed Class 12 clause from ICA 2025, widened NIBL’s trade mark rights.
- Whether NIBL’s Class 12 registration defeats NRB’s passing off claim in light of Sections 27(2) and 28(3) of the Trade Marks Act.
- Whether NRB established a prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury, and which ancillary reliefs (name change, “NRB Group” references, blue get-up, Dhannur address, court receiver) were warranted.
NRB Bearings Limited’s Arguments
-
-
- The Scheme allowed NIBL to use “NRB Industrial” only for industrial bearings, while the basic “NRB” mark, colour and logo remained with NRB.
- ICA 2025, for which NRB paid Rs. 55.12 crore, limited NIBL to NRB Industrial and NRB Industrial Bearings, in prescribed Pantone colours, and barred it from claiming to be part of the NRB Group.
- Expiry of the non-compete only freed NIBL to enter automotive bearings, not to use NRB-formative marks there.
- NRB relied on Syed Mohideen v. P. Sulochana Bai ((2016) 2 SCC 683) and Laxmikant V. Patel v. Chetanbhai Shah ((2002) 3 SCC 65) for passing off based on prior use and goodwill, and on its blue packaging used since before 1995.
-
NRB Industrial Bearings Limited’s Arguments
-
-
- NIBL holds Class 12 and Class 7 registrations for NRB Industrial, while NRB’s own applications for that mark never matured.
- Clause 1.5.5(c) transferred the mark unconditionally, with sub-brands and extensions, and the “industrial application” words only described the asset.
- NRB proposed a Class 12 restriction and cancellation during negotiations, and NIBL had it deleted, so the final ICA 2025 cannot be read to contain it.
- The payment of Rs. 55.12 crore settled differences over the Dhannur premises and trade mark use generally, and NIBL volunteered to drop “NRB Group” and blue colour in future promotions.
-
Court’s Observations and Analysis
A business right is not a brand right
The court noted that the Scheme divided the bearings business in two, with the industrial undertaking moving to NIBL and the mobile vehicle business staying with NRB. The court observed that the transferred asset was the NRB Industrial trademark “for bearings for industrial application”, and those words identify the goods for which NIBL may use it. The court held that the right to carry on a business and the right to use a trademark in that business are separate, so the lapse of the six-year non-compete on 30 September 2018 freed NIBL to sell automotive bearings but did not enlarge its NRB Industrial trademark rights.
Registration does not answer passing off
The court reasoned that NIBL’s Class 12 registration shows only an entry in the Register, and an entry does not prove use. Relying on Century Traders v. Roshan Lal Duggar & Co. (1977 SCC OnLine Del 50) and S. Syed Mohideen, the court stated that registration is irrelevant in a passing off action and that Section 28(3) does not take away the common law remedy preserved by Section 27(2). The court found that NRB showed use of NRB since 1965, with dealers, turnover and packaging, while NIBL showed no prior use of the NRB Industrial trademark for mobile vehicle bearings.
Negotiation history cannot rewrite the Agreement
The court observed that a clause deleted during negotiations cannot be treated as part of ICA 2025. It further observed that deleting a clause requiring cancellation of the registration is different from deciding how a registered mark may be used. Clause 4.2 let NIBL keep its registrations, yet made their use subject to the agreed restrictions, and Clause 4.1 allowed use only “in terms of the Demerger Order”. The court opined that NIBL could not rely on its registration to escape those undertakings.
Tailoring the injunction
The court found that the three interim injunction requirements were met for mobile vehicle bearings, because the goods are of a similar nature, NRB remains the prominent element, and confusion about a connection with the NRB Group is likely. The court noted that NIBL remains free to sell automotive bearings under another mark, so the balance of convenience favoured NRB. The court stated that a receiver was unnecessary, that blue packaging was not shown to be copied since NIBL’s product used red packaging, and that validity of the Class 12 registration was not before it in these Section 9 proceedings, so rectification and cancellation remedies stay open for NRB.
Findings
In view of the observations and the arguments presented by both the parties, the Bombay High Court held that:
-
-
- NRB made out a prima facie case of breach of contractual restrictions and passing off, and NIBL is restrained from using “NRB Industrial”, “NRB Industrial Bearings”, “NRB INDL” or any deceptively similar mark for mobile vehicle bearings, including automotive and farm equipment bearings.
- NIBL may sell such bearings under another lawful mark and may continue using NRB Industrial for industrial bearings, strictly per the Scheme and Clauses 4.1, 4.2 and 4.4 of ICA 2025.
- NIBL’s undertakings not to use “NRB Group” or blue colour in promotions are accepted, and it must not represent any association with the NRB Group or use the Dhannur address as its present office.
- NIBL must complete the removal of “NRB” from the name of NRB IBC Bearings Private Limited within six weeks and disclose unsold stock by affidavit within two weeks.
- Prayers for a court receiver and for cancellation of the Class 12 registration are rejected, with rectification remedies kept open, and the request for stay is refused.
-
Case Citation: NRB Bearings Limited v. NRB Industrial Bearings Limited, Commercial Arbitration Petition (L) No. 35424 of 2026, High Court of Judicature at Bombay, decided on 4 November 2026. Available at http://indiankanoon.org/doc/167362224/.
Authored by Gaurav Mishra, IP Attorney, BananaIP Counsels