Copyrights

TV Today Anti-Suit Injunction: Delhi HC Halts US Copyright Suit

Magnifying glass over a short storm clip on a news editing timeline, weather footage copyright fair dealing. Featured image for: TV Today Anti-Suit Injunction: Delhi HC Halts US Copyright Suit

Summary

T.V. Today Network Limited, the broadcaster behind Aaj Tak and India Today, faced a copyright infringement suit in a California federal court filed by a US weather-footage company and five US-based videographers over 42 news videos uploaded to YouTube from India. The broadcaster asked the Delhi High Court to stop the US proceedings, arguing that the videos were made in India, that brief clips of natural events were fair dealing for news reporting, and that YouTube's standard US jurisdiction clause could not move the dispute abroad. The Delhi High Court granted an interim anti-suit injunction, holding the US suit prima facie vexatious and oppressive. The TV Today anti-suit injunction is significant because it signals that platform boilerplate accepted while seeking restoration of content will not, by itself, displace an Indian forum for disputes rooted in Indian conduct.

Background

Forty-two news videos, a few seconds of storm footage in each, and a lawsuit filed nearly 13,000 kilometres away: that was the setting for the TV Today anti-suit injunction granted by the Delhi High Court on 5 November 2026.

T.V. Today Network Limited (“TV Today”), which runs Aaj Tak and India Today Television, published YouTube news reports between 2022 and 2025 on weather events abroad, scripted, edited and uploaded from India with its own narration and graphics. Global Weather Productions LLC (“Global Weather”), a US company claiming rights in weather recordings, and five US residents claiming authorship of certain clips (together, the “US Claimants”) asserted ownership of some of this footage.

In March 2026, their complaints led YouTube to disable several videos. TV Today filed counter-notifications under YouTube’s procedure, which required consent to US jurisdiction. On 18 March 2026, the US Claimants sued TV Today in the US District Court for the Northern District of California over 42 videos, alleging copyright infringement and removal of copyright management information (the “US Suit”), and later rejected a licensing proposal.

TV Today sued before the Delhi High Court for a declaration of non-infringement, relief against groundless threats under Section 60 of the Copyright Act, 1957 (“Copyright Act”) and an anti-suit injunction. Global Weather appeared but filed no reply, and the individual US Claimants stayed away despite service.

Issues

      • Whether the US Claimants, all based abroad, were amenable to the Delhi High Court’s jurisdiction for the purpose of an anti-suit injunction.
      • Whether the US jurisdiction clause in YouTube’s counter-notification procedure amounted to a choice of forum that displaced Indian courts.
      • Whether TV Today made out a prima facie case under Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act, read with the de minimis principle, for brief use of weather footage in news reporting.
      • Whether the US Suit was vexatious and oppressive so as to justify an interim anti-suit injunction consistent with comity.

TV Today’s Arguments

      • Every challenged act, including scripting, editing and uploading, took place in India for Indian audiences; TV Today has no US office, and its personnel, records and evidence sit in India.
      • The counter-notifications sought only restoration of content; they did not amount to consent to standalone US infringement and copyright management information claims.
      • The US jurisdiction clause was a non-negotiable term imposed by YouTube, not a bargained choice of forum between the parties.
      • Recordings of natural weather events capture facts, which are not protected by copyright, and their use for a few seconds in news narration is fair dealing for reporting current events under Section 52(1)(a)(iii), as well as de minimis.
      • Relying on the Supreme Court’s anti-suit jurisprudence and an earlier Delhi High Court order restraining similar US proceedings against an Indian media house, TV Today argued that forcing it to litigate Indian-law questions abroad was oppressive and risked conflicting decisions.
      • Without interim relief, TV Today would suffer irreparable harm to its content library, audience reach and reputation.

US Claimants’ Position

      • Global Weather entered appearance but filed no reply to the application, and the five individual US Claimants did not appear despite service, so TV Today’s factual averments stood uncontroverted.
      • YouTube’s owner and the former employee were represented, but the order records no substantive submissions from them on the anti-suit prayer.

Court’s Analysis

Harm felt in India brings foreign claimants within reach

The court observed that the cause of action arose in India, because the videos were conceived, produced and uploaded here, and the takedowns injured TV Today here. On that basis, the court held that the US Claimants were prima facie amenable to its jurisdiction, which is the threshold condition for any anti-suit injunction.

A power to be used sparingly, but used where justice demands

The court reasoned from the Supreme Court’s ruling in Oil and Natural Gas Commission v. Western Company of North America ((1987) 1 SCC 496) that Indian courts may restrain persons within their jurisdiction from pursuing foreign proceedings where the ends of justice require it, and that compelling a party to litigate Indian-law questions abroad can itself be oppressive. The court further observed, drawing on Modi Entertainment Network v. W.S.G. Cricket Pte. Ltd. ((2003) 4 SCC 341), that the remedy rests on three pillars: the defendant must be amenable to the court’s jurisdiction, refusal must defeat the ends of justice, and the principle of comity must be respected. The court opined that, where more than one forum is available, oppressive proceedings or those brought in a forum non conveniens may be restrained, though sparingly.

Platform boilerplate is not a forum selection

The heart of the TV Today anti-suit injunction lies in how the court treated YouTube’s counter-notification terms. The court stated that the only link to the United States was a standard-form clause in YouTube’s process, which TV Today accepted only to restore its videos. Such a clause, the court held, was not a negotiated forum choice between the disputing parties and could not, prima facie, shift a dispute arising entirely from conduct in India to a foreign court.

The court further observed that continuing the US Suit would subject Indian conduct to foreign law while the same issues were pending in India, risking conflicting decisions.

Storms are facts, and news needs them

On the prima facie merits, the court relied on a 2026 Delhi High Court ruling to hold that recordings of natural events capture generic facts lacking originality in the event itself. The court noted that TV Today used only brief extracts within its own narration to report current events, which brought the use within fair dealing for reporting under Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act. The court also applied the de minimis principle to such fleeting use.

Balance of convenience and the vexation test

The court reasoned that the balance of convenience favoured TV Today, since the US Claimants lost nothing of substance: they remained free to pursue their claims before Indian courts. Taking these factors together, the court held that the US Suit was prima facie vexatious and oppressive, and that a prima facie case for the TV Today anti-suit injunction was made out. The court clarified that all of its observations were tentative and would not bind the final adjudication of the suit.

Findings

In view of the observations and the arguments presented by both the parties, the Delhi High Court held that:

    • The US Claimants were prima facie amenable to the court’s jurisdiction because the cause of action arose in India.
    • YouTube’s standard-form US jurisdiction clause did not, prima facie, displace the Indian forum.
    • TV Today established a prima facie case of fair dealing under Section 52(1)(a)(iii) of the Copyright Act and de minimis use.
    • The US Suit was prima facie vexatious and oppressive, and the balance of convenience and irreparable harm favoured TV Today.
    • Until final disposal of the suit, Global Weather and the individual US Claimants, along with their agents and representatives, stand restrained from pursuing the US Suit and from initiating any proceedings outside India on the subject matter of the Indian suit.
    • TV Today must serve the order on the US Claimants by email, and the suit will next appear before the Joint Registrar on 9 February 2027.

Case Citation:  T.V. Today Network Limited v. Global Weather Productions LLC & Ors., CS(COMM) 738/2026, High Court of Delhi, decided on 5 November 2026. Available at https://indiankanoon.org/doc/178139985/

Authored by Gaurav Mishra, IP Attorney, BananaIP Counsels