The Delhi High Court confirmed the refusal of Mahesh Gupta’s patent application for a Portable Vehicle Management System, citing the lack of an inventive step in light of prior arts D4 and D5. The decision underscores important principles of patentability, including mosaicing, hindsight bias, and the criteria for non-obviousness.
Read more about Patent on Portable Vehicle Management System goes offtrackTag: Non Obviousness
Could an advanced Chat GPT be ‘the person skilled in the art’ for patent prosecution?
This post gives a general overview on the possibilities of Artificial Intelligence (AI) models such as ChatGPT, in providing useful assistance in the Patent examination process.
Read more about Could an advanced Chat GPT be ‘the person skilled in the art’ for patent prosecution?Important Patent Case law – 2021
In this post, we bring to you Important Patent Cases decided by Indian Courts in year 2021 FMC Corporation & ANR. vs Natco Pharma Limited...
Read more about Important Patent Case law – 2021Latest Patent Cases in 2021 – Part 3
Novartis Ag & Anr. vs Natco Pharma Limited & Anr. This case relates to a patent covering Eltrombopag Olamine (Eltrombopag bis(monoethanolamine)) held by Novartis. The...
Read more about Latest Patent Cases in 2021 – Part 3Non-Obviousness and the Trilogy
This post was first published on 5th December, 2014. The Supreme Court's non-obviousness precedent commenced with Graham v. John Deere Co., and its companion cases, Calmar...
Read more about Non-Obviousness and the TrilogyThe TSM Test and Non-obviousness
This post was first published on 6th December, 2014. TSM test is the Teaching, Suggestion and Motivation test. It simply means, when analysing the obviousness...
Read more about The TSM Test and Non-obviousnessThe Non-Obviousness Requirement and its Evolution – Graham vs. John Deere
This post was first published on 16th July, 2014. Today's special is the case that has set a high precedent in US Patent Law practice,...
Read more about The Non-Obviousness Requirement and its Evolution – Graham vs. John DeereFrom Dress Pin to Safety Pin
This post was first published on 2nd September, 2014. Inventive step / Non-Obviousness is one of the most important patentability criteria in almost all patent jurisdictions. Non-obviousness...
Read more about From Dress Pin to Safety PinPatent Prosecution in the Automobile Industry
[slideshare id=54003284&doc=patentprosecution-151016030727-lva1-app6892] This presentation was delivered by Aishwarya Narayan as a part of the course for senior management and IP Officers in the...
Read more about Patent Prosecution in the Automobile IndustrySpecial 301 Report: Chapter V. Inventive Step & 3(d) – Comprehending Apprehension or Apprehending Comprehension?
Is Section 3(d) an extension of the Inventive Step analysis? The answer to this question can make a difference to the compliance of non-discrimination obligations...
Read more about Special 301 Report: Chapter V. Inventive Step & 3(d) – Comprehending Apprehension or Apprehending Comprehension?