{"id":150711,"date":"2026-11-19T08:28:03","date_gmt":"2026-11-19T02:58:03","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/?p=150711"},"modified":"2026-11-19T08:28:03","modified_gmt":"2026-11-19T02:58:03","slug":"can-you-patent-what-everyone-already-knows-combination-patent","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/can-you-patent-what-everyone-already-knows-combination-patent\/","title":{"rendered":"Can You Patent What Everyone Already Knows? Madras High Court Says Yes to a Combination Patent"},"content":{"rendered":"<h2>Background<\/h2>\n<p>Twelve prior art documents, spanning nearly three decades of baling technology from the United States and Europe, could not unravel a single Indian patent on a twine baler. In a ruling on the reach of combination patent protection, the Madras High Court held that an invention assembled from individually known features can still be novel when the particular combination is new.<\/p>\n<p>M\/s Bull Agro Implements (&#8220;Bull Agro&#8221;), a Coimbatore partnership joined by two of its partners, has made agricultural implements for over 25 years and baler machines for about eight, and says it has sold over 1,000 balers of its own design. Ashlyn Antony (&#8220;Antony&#8221;) holds Patent No. 458805, &#8220;Baler for tying round blade using twine&#8221;, granted by the Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs (&#8220;Controller&#8221;) on 12 October 2023 under the Patents Act, 1970 (&#8220;Patents Act&#8221;).<\/p>\n<p>On 22 January 2024, Antony sent Bull Agro a cease-and-desist notice alleging infringement, and had also opposed a patent application filed by one of Bull Agro&#8217;s partners. Bull Agro replied denying novelty and then petitioned the Madras High Court for revocation under Section 64 of the Patents Act. The court framed issues on 17 June 2025, and neither side led oral evidence.<\/p>\n<h1>Issues<\/h1>\n<ol>\n<li style=\"list-style-type: none;\">\n<ol>\n<li>Whether the invention was publicly known before the priority date, or lacked novelty over the twelve cited prior arts.<\/li>\n<li>Whether the claimed combination was obvious under Section 64(1)(f), or not an invention under Section 64(1)(d).<\/li>\n<li>Whether the specification was insufficient under Section 64(1)(h), or the claims unclear and not fairly based on it under Section 64(1)(i).<\/li>\n<li>Whether non-working of the patent could support revocation under Section 64.<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<\/li>\n<\/ol>\n<h2>Petitioners&#8217; Arguments (Bull Agro)<\/h2>\n<ul>\n<li style=\"list-style-type: none;\">\n<ul>\n<li>The bale-tying mechanism had been used for decades, and twelve prior arts showed Antony&#8217;s claims were neither new nor inventive.<\/li>\n<li>Prior art 11 disclosed the same blade and sprocket movement of twine, and the duck bill assembly in prior art 12 (EP1882409B1) was in substance Antony&#8217;s backstop clutch.<\/li>\n<li>The specification was insufficient under Section 64(1)(h), the claims were not fairly based under Section 64(1)(i), and Antony sought to monopolise a basic mechanism that was no invention under Section 64(1)(d).<\/li>\n<li>Antony had not made or sold a single machine since grant.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<h2>Respondent&#8217;s Arguments (Antony)<\/h2>\n<ul>\n<li style=\"list-style-type: none;\">\n<ul>\n<li>The patent claimed an integrated combination of a chain drive on a link plate, a side backstop clutch holding the twine for the next cycle, and a blade beneath the clutch that cuts at a set bale density and stops the twine, which no prior art disclosed.<\/li>\n<li>The combination produced a technical effect absent in the prior art, and the apparatus qualified as an invention under Section 2(1)(j).<\/li>\n<li>The petition was a counter-blast to the cease-and-desist notice, and Bull Agro offered no evidence that a skilled person tried and failed to build the baler.<\/li>\n<li>Non-working is not a revocation ground under Section 64, and the Form 27 statement under Section 146(2) and Rule 131 of the Patents Rules, 2003 (&#8220;Patents Rules&#8221;) was not yet due.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<h1>Court&#8217;s Analysis<\/h1>\n<h2>Defining the Claim Before Testing the Prior Art<\/h2>\n<p>The court noted that it first had to understand what Antony claimed: an integrated assembly of a chain drive on a link plate, a side backstop clutch and a blade mounted beneath it. The court stated that it must ask whether any prior art disclosed that combination, and whether any teaching would lead a skilled person simply to assemble it. The court observed that Bull Agro sued only after the cease-and-desist notice, but treated this conduct as no more than an additional factor.<\/p>\n<h2>Twelve Prior Arts, No Matching Combination<\/h2>\n<p>The court found that the helical twine-winding device of 1979 had no backstop clutch and no blade beneath one, let alone a density-triggered cut. The court observed that the tape-binding, sheet-wrapping and web-dispensing balers lacked both a chain drive on a link plate and a twine-holding clutch. On prior art 11, the court held that a post-baling device severing twine from a finished bale could not be compared with a baler&#8217;s tying mechanism.<\/p>\n<h2>The Duck Bill Is Not a Backstop Clutch<\/h2>\n<p>The court found that the European duck bill device had no chain drive on a link plate, did not stop twine movement while cutting, and used a separate cutter. The court reasoned that the duck bill merely grips web material between clamped plates, while Antony&#8217;s clutch is a catcher body with a spring-loaded lock plate that opens at a predetermined density and closes again to hold the twine for the next cycle.<\/p>\n<h2>Known Parts, Novel Whole<\/h2>\n<p>The court then addressed the heart of the challenge to the combination patent. The court opined that even if the invention drew on features already known in the field, a particular combination that is novel and capable of industrial application deserves protection, and it found clear technical advancements over the cited art. Endorsing the Controller&#8217;s grant order as comprehensive, the court held that no ground arose under Section 64(1)(f) or Section 64(1)(d). The ruling confirms that a combination patent cannot be defeated by locating each element in a different document when nothing points to the combination as a whole.<\/p>\n<h2>Sufficiency and Non-Working<\/h2>\n<p>The court reasoned that Bull Agro&#8217;s own petition showed it had understood the structure and operation of the baler, and found that claims 1 to 7 disclosed every feature with its numbered element. With no evidence of a failed attempt by a skilled person, the Section 64(1)(h) and Section 64(1)(i) challenges failed. The court further noted that under Section 146(2) read with Rule 131 of the Patents Rules, the first Form 27 statement was not yet due, and held that non-working is not a ground for revocation under Section 64.<\/p>\n<h1>Findings<\/h1>\n<p>In view of the observations and the arguments presented by both the parties, the Madras High Court held that:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li style=\"list-style-type: none;\">\n<ul>\n<li>None of the twelve prior arts disclosed the claimed combination, so the patent was novel.<\/li>\n<li>A combination of known features is patentable when the particular combination is novel and capable of industrial application.<\/li>\n<li>No ground for revocation arose under Section 64(1)(f) or Section 64(1)(d).<\/li>\n<li>The specification was sufficient and the claims fairly based, defeating the Section 64(1)(h) and Section 64(1)(i) challenges.<\/li>\n<li>Non-working is not a ground for revocation, and the Form 27 statement was not yet due.<\/li>\n<li>The revocation petition was dismissed, with no order as to costs.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p><em><strong>Case Citation<\/strong>: Bull Agro Implements &amp; Ors. v. Ashlyn Antony &amp; Anr.<\/em>, OP (PT) No. 4 of 2024 (2026:MHC:4560), Madras High Court, decided on 13 November 2026. Available at<a href=\"https:\/\/indiankanoon.org\/doc\/5245483\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\"> https:\/\/indiankanoon.org\/doc\/5245483\/\u00a0<\/a><\/p>\n<p><strong>Authored by Gaurav Mishra, Patent Attorney, BananaIP Counsels<\/strong><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>Can a combination patent built from individually known features survive a revocation challenge backed by twelve prior arts? In Bull Agro Implements v. Ashlyn Antony, the Madras High Court examined novelty, inventive step, sufficiency of disclosure and non-working of a twine baler patent before reaching a clear answer.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":12,"featured_media":150714,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"iawp_total_views":4,"footnotes":""},"categories":[5495,6,14],"tags":[13347,13346,13345,13344,12663,83,1957,678,71,11746],"class_list":["post-150711","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-case-reviews","category-intellectual-property","category-patents","tag-agricultural-machinery-patent","tag-ashlyn-antony","tag-bull-agro-implements","tag-combination-patent","tag-insufficient-disclosure","tag-inventive-step","tag-madras-high-court","tag-novelty","tag-patent-revocation","tag-section-64-patents-act"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/150711","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/12"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=150711"}],"version-history":[{"count":3,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/150711\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":150715,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/150711\/revisions\/150715"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/150714"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=150711"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=150711"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=150711"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}