{"id":150693,"date":"2026-11-17T08:00:15","date_gmt":"2026-11-17T02:30:15","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/?p=150693"},"modified":"2026-11-15T11:13:34","modified_gmt":"2026-11-15T05:43:34","slug":"nehle-pe-dehla-copyright-damages","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/nehle-pe-dehla-copyright-damages\/","title":{"rendered":"Double Assignment, Double Trouble: Copyright Damages in Nehle Pe Dehla"},"content":{"rendered":"<h2>Background<\/h2>\n<h3>Copyright Assignment Dispute<\/h3>\n<p>This case relates to the video copyrights in the Hindi feature film Nehle Pe Dehla. The story of these rights begins in 2002, when Qamar Films assigned copyrights in the film to Showman Export (I) Pvt. Ltd. (Showman) by an agreement dated 4 February 2002. Dhariwal Films Pvt. Ltd. (Dhariwal Films), which was connected with the production of the film, was part of this transaction, as its Director signed the agreement as a confirming party.<\/p>\n<p>Three years later, in 2005, Dhariwal Films approached Ultra Distributors Pvt. Ltd. (Ultra) and offered to assign the video rights in the same film. While making the offer, it informed Ultra about the earlier assignment to Showman, but stated that the assignment had been cancelled in November 2002. Relying on this statement, Ultra entered into an Assignment Agreement dated 31 March 2005, under which it received the video rights, cable TV rights and video on demand rights in the film for India, Nepal and Bhutan for eight years. The total consideration was Rs. 42,51,000, of which Ultra paid Rs. 10,01,000.<\/p>\n<p>To enable Ultra to release the film on video, Dhariwal Films had to supply Digibeta Master tapes of a quality fit for commercial release. According to Ultra, this did not happen, as the tapes supplied were not of acceptable quality. Instead, Dhariwal Films allowed another VCD and DVD distributor, Defendant No. 2, to exploit the video rights. Defendant No. 2, for its part, claimed that Showman had assigned the video rights to it on 30 May 2002, and that Dhariwal Films had confirmed this assignment by a Deed of Assignment dated 28 August 2002.<\/p>\n<p>In an attempt to settle their differences, Ultra and Dhariwal Films signed Consent Terms, which confirmed that Ultra&#8217;s assignment was valid and recorded a higher value for the rights. These Consent Terms were, however, never filed in Court, and the dispute continued. Ultra therefore filed a suit in 2007 seeking a declaration of its rights, a declaration that the competing agreements were void and an injunction, and later amended the suit to claim damages of Rs. 1,66,75,000. Defendant No. 2 also filed its own suit claiming the same rights, but that suit was dismissed in April 2026, as the eight year term of its agreement had come to an end.<\/p>\n<h2>Questions Before the Court<\/h2>\n<ul>\n<li>Whether the assignment dated 31 March 2005 in favour of Ultra was valid and binding.<\/li>\n<li>Whether Dhariwal Films delivered Digibeta Master tapes of a quality fit for commercial exploitation.<\/li>\n<li>Whether Ultra was entitled to damages and, if so, how the damages should be assessed.<\/li>\n<li>Whether Defendant No. 2 had acquired an earlier and exclusive title to the video copyrights in the film.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<h2>Arguments Presented By the Parties<\/h2>\n<p>Ultra argued that:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Dhariwal Films had admitted Ultra&#8217;s rights in its pleadings in the other suit and in the Consent Terms, and could not deny them later.<\/li>\n<li>As Dhariwal Films had not denied, in its Written Statement, the specific plea that it failed to deliver usable master tapes, it was taken to have admitted that plea.<\/li>\n<li>Its evidence on damages remained unchallenged, since Dhariwal Films neither cross examined its witnesses on this point nor led any evidence of its own.<\/li>\n<li>Even where the exact loss cannot be proved, the Court may make a reasonable estimate, and the conduct of Dhariwal Films justified punitive damages as well.<\/li>\n<li>The documents relied upon by Defendant No. 2 were inconsistent with one another, and could not establish a chain of title.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Dhariwal Films argued that:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Ultra knew about the earlier assignment to Showman when it signed its agreement, and therefore had no cause of action.<\/li>\n<li>Ultra failed to pay the additional consideration agreed under the Consent Terms, and raised the quality of the tapes only to avoid that payment.<\/li>\n<li>Having refused the refund offered in January 2007, Ultra could not later seek damages.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Defendant No. 2 argued that:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>Its assignment was earlier in time and complete, as it had paid the entire consideration of Rs. 42,00,000.<\/li>\n<li>Dhariwal Films had itself admitted that Defendant No. 2 had a better title, and Ultra knew of these rights before signing its agreement.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<h2>Court&#8217;s Analysis<\/h2>\n<h3>Validity of the Assignment<\/h3>\n<p>The Court began by noting that Dhariwal Films had never disputed either signing the 2005 agreement or receiving Rs. 10,01,000 under it. The real question, therefore, was not whether the assignment existed, but whether it would stand against the rights claimed by Defendant No. 2. On this question, the Court found that Ultra had entered into the agreement because Dhariwal Films had represented that the earlier assignment to Showman had been cancelled.<\/p>\n<p>This finding was supported by what Dhariwal Films had itself said earlier. In the suit filed by Defendant No. 2, Dhariwal Films had stated that the rights were with Ultra and had questioned the authority of Showman to assign them. Similarly, in the Consent Terms, it had confirmed that Ultra&#8217;s assignment was binding, valid and subsisting. Since these earlier positions could not be reconciled with its later stand in support of Defendant No. 2, the Court observed that they reflected a lack of credibility and commercial dishonesty on the part of Dhariwal Films.<\/p>\n<p>The argument that Ultra knew about the Showman assignment did not help Dhariwal Films either. According to the Court, such knowledge did not make Ultra&#8217;s assignment conditional, because Dhariwal Films had represented that the earlier assignment stood cancelled and had led no evidence to show otherwise. The Court therefore held that the 2005 assignment was valid and binding.<\/p>\n<h3>Delivery of Master Tapes<\/h3>\n<p>Having upheld the assignment, the Court turned to whether Dhariwal Films had performed its side of the bargain. It explained that the question was not whether some tapes were handed over, but whether the tapes were good enough for commercial release. Ultra had specifically pleaded that they were not, and Dhariwal Films had not specifically denied this plea in its Written Statement. Relying on the Supreme Court decision in Thangam v. Navamani Ammal, the Court held that a general or evasive denial is not enough, and that Dhariwal Films must therefore be taken to have admitted the plea. As Dhariwal Films also produced no evidence of delivering usable tapes, the Court held that it had failed to perform this obligation.<\/p>\n<h3>Assessment of Damages<\/h3>\n<p>Since Ultra did not press its claim for a refund, the dispute on relief narrowed down to damages. On this aspect, Ultra&#8217;s witnesses had given evidence on the loss suffered and on the expenses incurred for publicity and printing of covers. Dhariwal Films, on the other hand, had neither cross examined them on this point nor led any evidence of its own. The Court therefore accepted Ultra&#8217;s evidence, and held that where the fact of loss is established, damages may be reasonably assessed even if the exact amount cannot be proved.<\/p>\n<p>The next step was to place a value on the rights that Ultra had lost. For this purpose, the Court relied on the Consent Terms, in which Dhariwal Films had itself valued the video rights at Rs. 82,51,000. By deducting the balance of Rs. 32,50,000 that Ultra still had to pay, the Court arrived at Rs. 50,01,000 as expectation damages, that is, the amount that would put Ultra where it would have been had the contract been performed. Taking this figure, the proved expenses and the overall evidence into account, the Court held that Ultra was entitled to compensatory damages of Rs. 1,66,75,000, the amount it had claimed.<\/p>\n<h3>Punitive Damages<\/h3>\n<p>The Court did not stop at compensation. It made it clear, however, that punitive damages were not being awarded merely because Dhariwal Films failed to perform the contract. Rather, they were awarded because of the manner in which Dhariwal Films had conducted itself. It had represented that the earlier assignment was cancelled, accepted money from Ultra, confirmed Ultra&#8217;s rights in the Consent Terms and questioned the title of Defendant No. 2 on oath, only to later support that very title. According to the Court, such conduct amounted to misrepresentation and cheating, and it therefore awarded punitive damages of Rs. 25,00,000.<\/p>\n<h3>Title Claimed by Defendant No. 2<\/h3>\n<p>Finally, the Court examined the claim of Defendant No. 2, which rested on a chain of agreements starting with the 2002 assignment to Showman. As Defendant No. 2 relied on this chain, the burden of proving it lay on Defendant No. 2. The Court found, however, that its documents did not show a clear and consistent chain of title, and that the answers of its witness in cross examination raised grave doubts about whether the documents were validly executed. Since Defendant No. 2 could not prove its own title, it also had no basis to challenge the assignment in favour of Ultra.<\/p>\n<h2>Findings<\/h2>\n<p>The findings of the Court are as follows:<\/p>\n<ul>\n<li>The assignment dated 31 March 2005 in favour of Ultra was valid and binding on Dhariwal Films.<\/li>\n<li>Ultra&#8217;s knowledge of the earlier assignment to Showman did not make its assignment conditional, as Dhariwal Films had represented that the earlier assignment was cancelled.<\/li>\n<li>Dhariwal Films failed to deliver Digibeta Master tapes of a quality fit for commercial exploitation.<\/li>\n<li>Where loss is established, damages may be reasonably assessed even if the exact amount cannot be proved, and on this basis Ultra was entitled to compensatory damages of Rs. 1,66,75,000.<\/li>\n<li>As Dhariwal Films created competing rights in the same film through representations it did not intend to honour, it was liable to pay punitive damages of Rs. 25,00,000.<\/li>\n<li>Defendant No. 2 failed to prove a valid chain of title to the video copyrights in the film.<\/li>\n<\/ul>\n<p>Based on these findings, the Court decreed the suit, declaring Ultra&#8217;s assignment valid and Ultra the exclusive holder of the assigned rights. It directed Dhariwal Films to pay Rs. 1,66,75,000 as damages, Rs. 25,00,000 as punitive damages and Rs. 15,00,000 as costs within eight weeks, failing which interest at 8 percent would apply.<\/p>\n<h2>Relevant Paras<\/h2>\n<h3>Paragraph 74<\/h3>\n<blockquote><p>&#8220;Also, the fact that the Plaintiff was aware that there had previously been an assignment involving Showman would not, ipso facto, assist Defendant No. 1 in its contention that the Plaintiff&#8217;s Assignment was in any manner conditional or contingent upon any previous assignment of rights. It is the Plaintiff&#8217;s specific case that Defendant No. 1 had represented to the Plaintiff that the earlier assignment stood cancelled. The Plaintiff, on this basis, entered into the Agreement dated 31st March 2005. [&#8230;]&#8221;<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<h3>Paragraph 85<\/h3>\n<blockquote><p>&#8220;Furthermore, it is now well settled, as held in the case of Koninklijke Philips N.V. v. MAJ (RETD) Sukesh Behl, Mahanagar Gas Ltd. v. Babulal Uttamchand and Co. and Board of Control for Cricket in India v. Kochi Cricket Private Limited, that a reasonable assessment of damages is permissible where the exact computation is rendered difficult by the nature of the breach and the evidence that is available. Therefore, just because in a given case the Plaintiff is unable to prove the precise quantum of loss or damages with exactitude, that would not, in an appropriate case, preclude an award of damages where the fact of loss is established and the available evidence furnishes a reasonable basis for the assessment of damages.&#8221;<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<h3>Paragraph 91<\/h3>\n<blockquote><p>&#8220;In addition to the above, I also find that the Plaintiff has made out a case for the grant of punitive damages. I say so not because Defendant No. 1 has failed to perform its obligations under the contract but because Defendant No. 1 has acted in a manner which clearly shows that Defendant No. 1 never really intended to and clearly sought to create multiple and competing rights in respect of the same Film on the basis of false representations or representations which Defendant No. 1 had no intention of honouring. [&#8230;]&#8221;<\/p><\/blockquote>\n<h2>Case Citation<\/h2>\n<p>Ultra Distributors Pvt. Ltd. v. M\/s. Dhariwal Films Pvt. Ltd. and 2 Ors., Commercial IP Suit No. 26 of 2007, Bombay High Court, judgment delivered 29 August 2026, Neutral Citation 2026:BHC-OS:19463, Indian Kanoon, available at <a href=\"http:\/\/indiankanoon.org\/doc\/14880555\/\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener\">http:\/\/indiankanoon.org\/doc\/14880555\/<\/a> (visited 12 November 2026).<\/p>\n<h2>Disclaimer<\/h2>\n<p>This case blog is based on the author&#8217;s understanding of the judgment. Understandings and opinions of others may differ. An AI application was used to generate parts of this case blog based on user inputs and prompts.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"<p>In the case of Ultra Distributors Pvt. Ltd. v. M\/s. Dhariwal Films Pvt. Ltd. and Ors., a film producer assigned the video copyrights in Nehle Pe Dehla to Ultra Distributors, but later supported a rival distributor who claimed the same rights under an earlier assignment. The Bombay High Court upheld the assignment in favour of Ultra Distributors and, because the producer had knowingly created competing rights in the same film, awarded punitive damages in addition to compensatory damages.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":3,"featured_media":150694,"comment_status":"closed","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"iawp_total_views":7,"footnotes":""},"categories":[3,5495,6],"tags":[12701,11895,312,5119,13339,13338],"class_list":["post-150693","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","hentry","category-copyrights","category-case-reviews","category-intellectual-property","tag-assignment-agreement","tag-assignment-of-rights","tag-bombay-high-court","tag-damages","tag-dhariwal-films-pvt-ltd","tag-ultra-distributors-pvt-ltd"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/150693","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/3"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=150693"}],"version-history":[{"count":3,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/150693\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":150706,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/150693\/revisions\/150706"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/150694"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=150693"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=150693"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.bananaip.com\/intellepedia\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=150693"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}